Knee pain when squatting often isn’t a knee problem. If your knee copes with full bend at bodyweight but hurts under load, something upstream is overloading it, usually a hip that won’t move or a glute that isn’t doing its share. Find that breakdown, fix it first, then rebuild the tendon’s capacity to handle load.
I can say that with confidence because it happened to me. I can squat and deadlift, but not at the level I used to. Around 90 kilos, my knees start to feel exposed. I’m not blaming my 40s. I don’t believe that’s the reason.
So I handed the problem to Shant, my go-to injury guy at Enterprise Fitness, and let him assess me on camera at our Abbotsford studio. Twenty minutes later, my squat felt completely different. Here’s exactly what he did.
Do you actually have a knee problem?
Shant’s first call surprised me: you don’t have a knee problem, you have a task-specific problem. He knows the difference. He was shot in the knee in the military. That’s a knee problem. Lying in bed and moving his leg hurt.
I could sit at the bottom of a bodyweight squat all day with no pain. If the knee tolerates full bend against gravity, the joint itself isn’t what’s failing. Something about the task, under load, is breaking down.
Think of a bridge that holds a car but creaks under a truck. You don’t tear up the deck. You go looking for the support that isn’t carrying its share.
When does your knee hurt?
The questions came before any testing, and they narrowed it fast. On a hack squat, up on my toes with my knees well forward, I had no problems at all. With my feet placed so I had to use my hips, the pain arrived straight away, on the way down and near the bottom.
That detail matters. Pain on the way down means your hips aren’t receiving the weight, so the knee takes more load than it should. Pain on the way up points to a force production problem instead. One question, two very different plans.
He also asked whether it eased as I warmed up. It did, with some achiness the next day if I pushed too hard. An ultrasound had already shown tendinopathy, and that pattern fits it.
What is knee tendinopathy?
It’s a tendon that has been overloaded. Shant treats “tendonitis” as an outdated term, because the issue isn’t really inflammation. The word that matters is overload. Once a tendon gets sensitive, it stops tolerating being stretched under load.
So the useful question isn’t “what’s wrong with my tendon?” It’s “what isn’t contributing, that’s leaving my tendon to do too much?” In Shant’s experience, the answer usually comes from the hips.
What did the assessment find?
Shoes off. Three simple screens, then a few more tests based on what showed up.
- Single-leg stance: I felt more stable on my left. But my left leg was making tiny inward rotations, a compensation giving me the feeling of stability.
- Toe touch: tightness high in the hamstring, just under the glute.
- Back bend: my left knee kept shifting forward to find the range.
- Low bar squat hold: the same left knee travelling forward at the bottom.
None of that was a diagnosis. It was a pattern forming. Then I lay on my back and Shant moved each hip by hand. The right was fine. The left was stuck, a good 20 to 30 degrees short, with a pinch and a clunk.
Last test: face down, straight leg lift, with his fingers on my hamstring and glute. On the left, the hamstring fired first and the glute lagged behind. There it was. A left hip that wouldn’t rotate outward and a glute barely firing into extension.
What exercises fixed it?
Not a pile of banded clams. Shant chose four things in a deliberate order, each with one job.
- Side-lying kickbacks with a band. Band above the knees, top leg straight and rotated out, then kick back. I managed 15 on the right. On the left I got less than half the range, so we dropped to sets of five. No swinging, only clean contractions.
- Banded side plank. Knees bent, band on, top leg lifted and straight, held for 10 seconds each side. This teaches the hip to hold that position.
- 10-second eccentric squats. Band just below the knees, 10 seconds down, normal speed up. You’re not pushing your knees open as you go. You’re keeping them open the whole way.
- Overcoming isometrics on the leg extension. This one is for the tendon. More below.
The retest after the first two told the story. The left hip that had taken real force now moved with two of Shant’s fingers. No clunk. After the slow squats, I did a normal low bar squat. It felt so much better.
Why do isometric holds help a sore tendon?
With the hip sorted, the tendon still needed work. Set the leg extension at roughly 45 degrees, use both legs to lift the weight into position, then let go with one leg and keep pushing hard against it for 30 seconds. Go heavy. Swap legs. After three or four of those, your quads burn and the knee pain tends to ease.
Shant uses a rowing boat to explain it. Your strongest rowers do most of the work early. Once they tire, the weaker rowers have to pull their weight. A 30-second hold does the same thing to the different parts of your tendon. It also lifts how well your quads can contract, which is why research by Ebonie Rio on isometrics matters here. Short term it eases pain. Long term it builds load capacity.
Why fix the hip before the tendon?
Because the tendon was the victim, not the cause. When the glute doesn’t contribute on the way down, other muscles take over and the tendon cops more stretch than it should. You can tolerate that up to a point. Past that threshold, the knee feels exposed.
Load the tendon without fixing the hip and you’re bailing out a boat without plugging the hole. It’s also why a change of technique alone rarely lasts. As Shant said, it’s an integrated system. The hip, the tendon and the nervous system all have to line up.
Notice one more thing: we started with my squat and finished with my squat. That first squat was the control. Change one thing, retest. Better? Do more of it. That’s how you know an exercise worked, instead of just hoping.
What should you do about your knee pain?
One session changed how my squat felt. It didn’t finish the job. The hip work has to happen consistently until it’s normal, and the tendon needs time to rebuild its capacity.
Start by answering this: when exactly does it hurt? Which exercise, which part of the rep, which side? Write it down. Then stop treating your knee and get the whole chain assessed. I’ve walked through the process in what happens in a personal training assessment, and this is the difference between a trainer who names the problem and one who solves it.
If your knee swelled up, locks, gives way, hurts at rest, or the pain started with a fall or a twist, see a physio or doctor before you train it. Otherwise, come and see us in Melbourne. Book a consultation and we’ll find out what your knee has been covering for.
Frequently asked questions
Why do my knees hurt when I squat but not when I walk?
Usually because the problem shows up under load, not in the joint itself. If your knee handles full bend at bodyweight, look upstream. A stiff hip or an underperforming glute can leave the knee and its tendon carrying too much once the bar gets heavy.
Should I stop squatting if my knee hurts?
Not automatically. Work out which part of the rep hurts, fix the movement breakdown and rebuild from there with slow, controlled squats. See a physio or doctor first if the knee swells, locks, gives way or hurts at rest.
What is the difference between tendonitis and tendinopathy?
Tendinopathy describes a tendon that has been overloaded and become sensitive. Tendonitis implies inflammation, which is why many clinicians now treat it as an outdated term. The focus shifts to why the tendon is overloaded and how to build its capacity.
Do isometric exercises help knee tendon pain?
They can. A heavy 30-second hold on the leg extension, pushing constantly, can ease pain in the short term and build the tendon’s load capacity over time. It works best after you’ve fixed whatever was overloading the tendon.
Can weak glutes cause knee pain?
Yes. When the glutes don’t contribute as you lower into a squat, other muscles take over and the knee tendon takes more stretch and load. In my assessment, a left hip that wouldn’t rotate and a lagging left glute were behind the problem.